Power plants – Combustion products used as motive fluid
Reexamination Certificate
1999-09-02
2001-10-30
Freay, Charles G. (Department: 3746)
Power plants
Combustion products used as motive fluid
C060S726000, C060S728000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06308512
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates generally to gas turbine power generation systems and more particularly relates to a supercharging system for improving the capacity of gas-turbine power plants at high ambient temperatures. Specifically, the system uses an auxiliary fan combined with a controller to pressurize inlet air to the turbine to allow operation with existing turbines; the auxiliary fan is preferably combined with an inlet air cooling system.
2. Background and Prior Art
It has long been recognized that the capacity of gas turbines declines with increasing inlet air temperature. The typical penalty is on the order of 0.4% per degree F. This characteristic is especially troublesome for gas turbines used in electrical power generation since the peak electricity demand usually coincides with the highest ambient air temperatures. Gas turbines and associated generators and power distribution systems are usually rated based on turbine capacity at 40 to 50° F. inlet air temperature. This low rating temperature means that the capacity reduction at summer-peaking conditions can amount to approximately 20 to 40% of turbine capacity, depending on the design, local weather conditions, and the characteristics of the particular turbine.
Many different approaches for cooling inlet air to the turbine in order to reduce or eliminate this capacity penalty are known in the prior art. A summary of these approaches is described in the ASME paper, “Options in Gas Turbine Power Augmentation Using Inlet Air Chilling,” Igor Ondryas et al., presented at the Gas Turbine and Aeroengine Congress and Exposition, Jun. 11-14, 1990, Brussels, Belgium. Among the alternatives for cooling are direct and indirect evaporative cooling, electric vapor-compression, absorption, and thermal storage systems.
Of these many alternatives, direct evaporative cooling is the only approach that has seen any significant commercial application. Direct evaporative cooling has the advantage of low cost and simplicity, but the ambient wet-bulb temperature limits the possible temperature reduction. For locations in the eastern U.S. direct evaporative cooling can reduce inlet air temperatures by 10 to 20° F., depending on the local climate. Larger reductions are possible in warm, dry climates such as those of the southwestern U.S. While direct evaporative cooling is helpful, it does not allow the turbines to run at their full design capacity. After over 50 years of intensive research and development in gas turbines, a better approach for dealing with high ambient temperatures has not been produced.
An interesting but virtually unused approach to address these problems is described in the paper, “Supercharging of Gas Turbines by Forced Draft Fans With Evaporative Intercooling” by R. W. Foster-Pegg, ASME 1965. This paper describes the use of a high-pressure fan to increase the inlet pressure to a gas turbine combined with an evaporative cooler downstream of the fan as a way of increasing turbine capacity, This approach can give large theoretical advantages, but it required special sizing of the generator which limited its use to new turbines. In addition the systems used a single fan with inlet vanes for control purposes, which reduced the efficiency of the system.
Kolp et al. show the economics of the supercharging and cooling systems in the ASME paper “Advantages of Air conditioning and supercharging an LM6000 Gas Turbine Inlet,” Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, July 1995, vol. 117, p 513-527. This paper shows that while evaporative cooling is extremely attractive, the economics of supercharging are not very attractive, with payback periods of over 10 years for simple cycles. Supercharging is more attractive in combined-cycle plants, but its economics are still marginal. The supercharging systems described in this paper are virtually identical to those from the 1960s, so supercharging has not advanced significantly despite decades of turbine development.
One very important problem in the prior art is that the supercharging arrangements require increasing the size of the associated generator and other auxiliary equipment. The cost of replacing the generator and other auxiliaries is so large that it effectively eliminates this possibility for existing plants. Even in new installations, supercharging may not be a practical option except at the very beginning of the project since the basic requirements of the generator, power distribution system, and associated hardware would have to change. As Kolp et al. state in their paper (page 520), “in contrast to supercharging, it is not necessary to increase the size of gas turbine plant equipment when adding evaporative cooling.” Thus the conventional wisdom is that evaporative cooling may be added to an existing power plant, but supercharging is not a retrofit option.
Another method for controlling turbine capacity involves a variable-speed compressor. Relevant patents include U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,853,432 and 2,693,080. These systems give a large range of control and were usually intended for use in aircraft applications. A major problem with these systems is the cost and complexity of the variable-speed compressor. Related problems are the reliability and maintenance related to the large gearing required for these systems. These systems have not seen significant use in power-generation applications.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In accordance with one preferred embodiment of the present invention, a system for improving gas turbine capacity at high ambient air temperatures comprises at least one auxiliary fan that pressurizes turbine inlet air and a controller for limiting maximum turbine capacity to that of the turbine without supercharging. The system preferably includes an air cooler for reducing turbine inlet air temperature. The system of the invention may be added to an existing gas turbine or designed for a new, supercharged, gas turbine system.
One of the principal objectives and advantages of the invention is to increase turbine capacity at summer-peaking conditions while reducing the installed cost of the system based on capacity at summer-peaking conditions. Related objectives of the invention are to create a system that does not have excessive complexity or space requirements and that does not create unacceptable reliability or maintenance problems. An additional objective is to develop a supercharger that allows practical retrofit of existing turbines.
REFERENCES:
patent: 2584232 (1952-02-01), Sedille
patent: 3394265 (1968-07-01), Hendrickson
patent: 3500636 (1970-03-01), Craig
patent: 3796045 (1974-03-01), Foster-Pegg
patent: 4731990 (1988-03-01), Munk
patent: 5353585 (1994-10-01), Munk
patent: 5537813 (1996-07-01), Davis et al.
patent: 5622044 (1997-04-01), Bronicki et al.
patent: 5655373 (1997-08-01), Yamashita et al.
patent: 5669217 (1997-09-01), Anderson
patent: 5675188 (1997-10-01), Utamura
patent: 5680752 (1997-10-01), Skog
patent: 5782093 (1998-07-01), Yamashita et al.
Foster-Pegg R.W., “Supercharging of Gas Turbines by Forced Draft Fans with Evaporative Intercooling”, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Jan. 7, 1965, pp. 1-12.
Foster-Pegg, R.W., “Trends in Combined Steam-Gas Turbine Power Plants in the U.S.A.”, Transactions of the ASME Journal of Engineering for Power, Oct. 1966, pp. 302-312.
Kolp, D.A., “Advantages of Air Conditioning and Supercharging an LM6000”, Transactions of the ASME Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, vol. 117, Jul. 1995, pp. 513-527.
Enhanced Turbine Output Holding LLC
Freay Charles G.
Rothwell Figg Ernst & Manbeck
LandOfFree
Supercharging system for gas turbines does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Supercharging system for gas turbines, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Supercharging system for gas turbines will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2579984