Boots – shoes – and leggings – Soles – Cushion
Reexamination Certificate
1995-01-23
2004-11-02
Kavanaugh, Ted (Department: 3728)
Boots, shoes, and leggings
Soles
Cushion
C036S103000, C036S029000, C036S03000A
Reexamination Certificate
active
06810606
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates generally to the structure of shoes. More specifically, this invention relates to the structure of running shoes. Still more particularly, this invention relates to variations in the structure of such shoes using a theoretically ideal stability plane as a basic concept.
Existing running shoes are unnecessarily unsafe. They profoundly disrupt natural human biomechanics. The resulting unnatural foot and ankle motion leads to what are abnormally high levels of running injuries.
Proof of the unnatural effect of shoes has come quite unexpectedly from the discovery that, at the extreme end of its normal range of motion, the unshod bare foot is naturally stable, almost unsprainable, while the foot equipped with any shoe, athletic or otherwise, is artificially unstable and abnormally prone to ankle sprains. Consequently, ordinary ankle sprains must be viewed as largely an unnatural phenomena, even though fairly common. Compelling evidence demonstrates that the stability of bare feet is entirely different from the stability of shoe-equipped feet.
The underlying cause of the universal instability of shoes is a critical but correctable design flaw. That hidden flaw, so deeply ingrained in existing shoe designs, is so extraordinarily fundamental that it has remained unnoticed until now. The flaw is revealed by a novel new biomechanical test, one that is unprecedented in its simplicity. It is easy enough to be duplicated and verified by anyone; it only takes a few minutes and requires no scientific equipment or expertise. The simplicity of the test belies its surprisingly convincing results. It demonstrates an obvious difference in stability between a bare foot and a running shoe, a difference so unexpectedly huge that it makes an apparently subjective test clearly objective instead. The test proves beyond doubt that all existing shoes are unsafely unstable.
The broader implications of this uniquely unambiguous discovery are potentially far-reaching. The same-fundamental flaw in existing shoes that is glaringly exposed by the new test also appears to be the major cause of chronic overuse injuries, which are unusually common in running, as well as other sport injuries. It causes the chronic injuries in the same way it causes ankle sprains; that is, by seriously disrupting natural foot and ankle biomechanics.
The applicant has introduced into the art the concept of a theoretically ideal stability plane as a structural basis for shoe designs. That concept as implemented into shoes such as street shoes and athletic shoes is presented in U.S. Pat. No. 4,989,349, issued on Feb. 5, 1991 and U.S. Pat. No. 5,317,819, issued Jun. 7, 1994, each of which is incorporated by reference, as well as in PCT Application No. PCT/US89/03076 filed on Jul. 14, 1989. This application develops the application of the concept of the theoretically ideal stability plane to other shoe structures and presents certain structural ideas presented in the PCT application.
Accordingly, it is a general object of this invention to elaborate upon the application of the principle of the theoretically ideal stability plane to other shoe structures.
It is another general object of this invention to provide a shoe sole which, when under load and tilting to the side, deforms in a manner which closely parallels that of the foot of its wearer, while retaining nearly the same amount of contact of the shoe sole with the ground as in its upright state.
It is still another object of this invention to provide a deformable shoe sole having the upper portion or the sides bent inwardly somewhat so that when worn the sides bend out easily to approximate a custom fit.
It is still another object of this invention to provide a shoe having a naturally contoured sole which is abbreviated along its sides to only essential structural stability and propulsion elements, which are combined and integrated into the same discontinuous shoe sole structural elements underneath the foot, which approximate the principal structural elements of a human foot and their natural articulation between elements.
These and other objects of the invention will become apparent from a detailed description of the invention which follows taken with the accompanying drawings.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Directed to achieving the aforementioned objects and to overcoming problems with prior art shoes, a shoe according to the invention comprises a sole having at least a portion thereof following the contour of a theoretically ideal stability plane, and which further includes rounded edges at the finishing edge of the sole after the last point where the constant shoe sole thickness is maintained. Thus, the upper surface of the sole does not provide an unsupported portion that creates a destabilizing torque and the bottom surface does not provide an unnatural pivoting edge.
In another aspect, the shoe includes a naturally contoured sole structure exhibiting natural deformation which closely parallels the natural deformation of a foot under the same load. In a preferred embodiment, the naturally contoured side portion of the sole extends to contours underneath the load-bearing foot. In another embodiment, the sole portion is abbreviated along its sides to essential support and propulsion elements wherein those elements are combined and integrated into the same discontinuous shoe sole structural elements underneath the foot, which approximate the principal structural elements of a human foot and their natural articulation between elements. The density of the abbreviated shoe sole can be greater than the density of the material used in an unabbreviated shoe sole to compensate for increased pressure loading. The essential support elements include the base and lateral tuberosity of the calcaneus, heads of the metatarsal, and the base of the fifth metatarsal.
The shoe sole is naturally contoured, paralleling the shape of the foot in order to parallel its natural deformation, and made from a material which, when under load and tilting to the side, deforms in a manner which closely parallels that of the foot of its wearer, while retaining nearly the same amount of contact of the shoe sole with the ground as in its upright state under load. A deformable shoe sole according to the invention may have its sides bent inwardly somewhat so that when worn the sides bend out easily to approximate a custom fit.
These and other features of the invention will become apparent from the detailed description of the invention which follows.
REFERENCES:
patent: 288127 (1883-11-01), Shepard
patent: 532429 (1895-01-01), Rogers
patent: 1289106 (1918-12-01), Bullock
patent: 2147197 (1939-02-01), Glidden
patent: 2179942 (1939-11-01), Lyne
patent: 2328242 (1943-08-01), Witherill
patent: 3308560 (1967-03-01), Jones
patent: 3824716 (1974-07-01), Di Paolo
patent: 3997984 (1976-12-01), Hayward
patent: 4030213 (1977-06-01), Daswick
patent: 4044479 (1977-08-01), Brutting
patent: 4083125 (1978-04-01), Benseler
patent: 4128951 (1978-12-01), Tansill
patent: 4141158 (1979-02-01), Benseler
patent: 4240214 (1980-12-01), Sigle et al.
patent: 4258480 (1981-03-01), Famolare, Jr.
patent: 4262433 (1981-04-01), Hagg et al.
patent: 4272858 (1981-06-01), Hlustik
patent: 4305212 (1981-12-01), Coomer
patent: 4308671 (1982-01-01), Bretschneider
patent: 4366634 (1983-01-01), Giese et al.
patent: 4449306 (1984-05-01), Cavanagh
patent: 4455767 (1984-06-01), Bergmans
patent: 4542598 (1985-09-01), Misevich et al.
patent: 4557059 (1985-12-01), Misevich
patent: 4559723 (1985-12-01), Hamy et al.
patent: 4578882 (1986-04-01), Talarico, II
patent: 4580359 (1986-04-01), Kurrash et al.
patent: 4715133 (1987-12-01), Hartjes et al.
patent: 4724622 (1988-02-01), Mills
patent: 4748753 (1988-06-01), Ju
patent: 4785557 (1988-11-01), Kelley et al.
patent: 4827631 (1989-05-01), Thornton
patent: 4858340 (1989-08-01), Pasternak
patent: 4989349 (1991-02-01), Ellis, III
patent: 5317819 (1994-06-01), Ellis, III
patent: 5544429 (1996-08-01), Ellis, III
patent: 5909945 (1999-06-01), Noy
patent: 6115941 (200
Anatomic Research Inc.
Kavanaugh Ted
Knoble & Yoshida & Dunleavy LLC
LandOfFree
Shoe sole structures incorporating a contoured side does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Shoe sole structures incorporating a contoured side, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Shoe sole structures incorporating a contoured side will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-3344214