Image analysis – Applications – Biomedical applications
Reexamination Certificate
2000-07-05
2003-06-24
Patel, Jayanti K. (Department: 2621)
Image analysis
Applications
Biomedical applications
C377S010000, C128S922000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06584217
ABSTRACT:
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to reflectometry systems in general, and more particularly to reflectometry systems and methods used to analyze change in a characteristic such as color or optical density of an area of a testing substrate. Such area may include colored spots that can represent a chemical condition in a specimen in a molecular recognition application (among other applications) to discern meaningful information from contrast signals.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
It is known in the art to analyze biological and other specimens using optical techniques, including automatic optical analysis systems. Often it is desired to detect the presence of a particular analyte potentially within a specimen by testing for a reaction of the analyte with a specific reagent that can bind to the analyte. Such molecular recognition reactions represent the complexing of molecules that possess a high binding affinity to each other.
For example, consider the detection of the analyte human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG), a hormone present in the urine of pregnant women, as an indication of pregnancy. A few drops of urine are exposed to a substrate having a reagent thereon that is known to bind to HCG. In performing such testing, additional reagents may be added to the testing substrate such that a change in characteristic (e.g., color) in at least a portion of the results if HCG is present in the urine. The resultant color change can be clearly visible to the untrained eye and can serve as a home pregnancy test.
At best, the human eye can give qualitative results. But often tests do not produce readily ascertainable “yes” or “no” results that are unambiguously apparent, even for a laboratory technician who is experienced in performing the tests and reading the results. Also, for some tests, quantitative results are desired, for example the measurement of progression or extent of a disease state. Visual examination of color and contrast changes are only qualitative, and the eyes of one observer will have a different sensitivity than the eyes of another observer. Even if two observers with identical visual sensitivity could be found, fatigue and subjective judgment differences could provide different results for identical data.
Many other molecular recognition applications, both immunological and non-immunological, can provide a meaningful contrast signal that can be analyzed using contrast data. In addition to immunological pair applications (e.g., antibody-antigen “Ab-Ag”), various sandwich format matrix assay techniques such as Ab/Ag/Ab, or Ag/Ab/Protein A-gold can generate meaningful contrast signals, as can bindings between avidin-biotin derivatives, or lectin-carbohydrate binding. Many applications use hormone receptors as molecular recognition sites, and reaction specific binding is a powerful analytical tool used in DNA hybridization. Such applications would benefit if more reliable and automated analytical tools could be provided.
Various systems have been attempted to provide an automated reliable system for analyzing results obtained from immunological and non-immunological molecular recognition applications. In some tests, especially those-involving immunoassay devices, it is necessary to discern the presence and reflectivity of dye-colored spots relative to the background area surrounding the spot. For example, when testing electrophoretic immunoblots (“Western Blots”) a densitometer is used to measure optical density of light reflected from nitrocellulose strips. But color density of antibody-produced color bands in the strips can vary, as can the background color. As a further complication, densitometers used in such tests cannot measure more than a single point in a color band. Thus, while densitometry can produce automated results, the results may vary greatly and can be highly inaccurate.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,006,464 to Chu et al. discloses the use of reflectometry to more rapidly quantitate the results of immunoassay tests. Suppose, for example, it is desired to examine human blood using such rapid immunoassay testing. A few drops of a blood, serum, or plasma specimen are deposited onto a testing substrate of an analytical device. The testing substrate is oftentimes a porous membrane that has one or more receptor chemicals bound thereon at discrete areas of the membrane that bindingly react to one or more target analytes, if present within the blood. Typically, after addition of the blood specimen, a few drops of a labeled reagent that may include a colored dye are added to the testing substrate. Finally, a few drops of a washing solution may be added to the testing substrate to remove any residual reagents that have not specifically bound to the discrete areas of the membrane where the receptor chemicals are located. The presence of the target analyte in the blood may then be indicated by the presence of a dye-colored spot on the device, relative to the uncolored surrounding background (which will be the area of the testing substrate that does not have receptor chemicals bound thereon). Such testing of course is not limited to the diagnosis of a particular analyte within blood, but may also be carried out with other types of specimens, biological or otherwise, that may contain target analytes of interest.
FIG. 1A
depicts an exemplary device
10
that may be used to carry out the above-described Chu type analysis. Device
10
may measure perhaps 1 cm square and, for reasons of economy, is fabricated from several layers of cardboard (or sometimes plastic) including upper and lower layers
20
,
30
. Upper layer
20
defines an opening
40
, perhaps 8 mm in diameter, that exposes a surface
50
that lies higher than bottom layer
30
. Surface
50
defines a membrane (or substrate) whose preferably porous surface contains at least one immobilized receptor chemical that will cause a binding reaction with a target analyte, when present in a specimen.
FIG. 1B
, is a top-view of the device depicted in
FIG. 1A
, after the above-described testing procedure has been carried out. Spot
60
, where a receptor chemical is adhered onto the testing substrate, is shown as being rather (ideally) circular and having a color that is in sharp contrast to the surrounding upper surface
70
of device
10
, indicating that the analyte of interest was present in the specimen tested. The challenge is to determine reflectivity of spot
60
relative to surrounding region
70
. Stated differently, the challenge is to distinguish between signal from spot
60
and a background reference level from region
70
. It will be appreciated that a small change in either signal can result in a substantial change in the difference between the two signals.
The ability to differentiate reflectivity signal from the background reference level permits one to arrive at a meaningful conclusion as to the presence or absence of the target analyte in the specimen. For example,
FIG. 1C
shows device
10
with no spot whatsoever, e.g., no binding reaction has occurred, and the target analyte is absent from the specimen. In
FIG. 1D
, a dark spot is present, but as may often be the case, the spot is not uniform in shape and may be smaller in size than anticipated. Spot size can be affected by the area of membrane
50
that was originally impregnated or otherwise treated with chemicals before the specimen was introduced.
FIG. 1E
depicts a uniform spot
60
, but of less opaqueness than the spot shown in
FIG. 1B
, while
FIG. 1F
shows a non-uniformly shaped spot of less opaqueness than was shown in
FIG. 1A
or FIG.
1
C.
It can be rather difficult to accurately discern reflectivity of spot
60
relative to the surrounding region
70
. This is especially true if distinguishing signal from noise is to be accomplished rapidly, preferably in an automated fashion, without requiring trained personnel. In many applications, the difference between a positive reading and a negative reading can be less than about a ±1% change in reflectivity. In practice, borderline readings often occur when spot reflectivity is per
Chu Albert E.
Lawless John L.
Choobin Barry
Dorsey & Whitney LLP
E Y Laboratories, Inc.
Patel Jayanti K.
LandOfFree
Reflectometry system with compensation for specimen holder... does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Reflectometry system with compensation for specimen holder..., we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Reflectometry system with compensation for specimen holder... will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-3159836