Games using tangible projectile – Golf – Club or club support
Reexamination Certificate
2001-06-18
2003-09-23
Sewell, Paul T. (Department: 3711)
Games using tangible projectile
Golf
Club or club support
C473S330000, C473S345000, C148S516000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06623376
ABSTRACT:
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates to a method of forming a compressive layer on a golf club head. More particularly, the invention relates to peening of surfaces, such as shot peening the inner surface of a club head and face, as well as a club head so formed.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Various golf club designs have been introduced in the marketplace to address the desire for equipment that has a long service life. In particular, manufacturers have produced club heads from a range of materials including metals and alloys such as stainless steel, aluminum, and titanium. In addition, club heads with variable face thickness have been developed, so that the stresses associated with the impact of a golf ball with a club face may be properly managed.
Titanium alloys typically used for golf club head manufacture include 6-4 (Ti-6% Al-4% V), due to its high strength to density ratio and stiffness (modulus of elasticity), and 15-3-3-3 (Ti-15% V-3% Cr-3% Al-3% Ni). Club faces may also be cold forged or stamped from as-rolled sheet stock of high strength SP-700 titanium alloy (Ti-4.5% Al-3% V-2% Mo-2% Fe). In addition, the face can be formed of a high strength forging titanium alloy such as 10-2-3 (Ti-10% V-2% Fe-3% Al). Typical face thicknesses for titanium alloy metal woods range from about 0.118 to 0.126 inches.
It is desirable to decrease the thickness of the face of the club head in order to redistribute the weight elsewhere within the head. However, there are limitations on the degree of thinness of the club face, as a function of the face material and treatment. For example, a club face that is too thin may be susceptible to catastrophic failure during impact, as it may be unable to withstand the impact stresses. Failure may occur, for example, proximate the impact region, as well as proximate high stress concentration zones such as scorelines. In addition, the fatigue life of a given club head may be decreased as a result of the thin club face, which may lead to premature failure of the club head after repeated stressing. Variable face thickness addresses some of the problems inherent with thin face designs; by providing an area of increased thickness proximate the center of the face, where ball impacts are intended to occur, a stronger club head may be obtained so that the stresses of impact do not affect the integrity of the club head. Adjacent regions may have reduced thickness as compared to the central region of the face, so that weight may be redistributed in the club head.
Mechanical and chemical surface treatments have long been used in golf club manufacturing to produce club heads with high quality, finished, exterior surfaces. The treatments, including shot peening, are typically used for aesthetic conditioning, i.e. creating exterior surfaces with a desirable look and feel, such as by cleaning or selectively roughening or smoothing the surface. The surfaces of some iron golf clubs from Taylor Made, Callaway, and Ping have been finished with shot peening. For example, Taylor Made's ICW-11 irons, produced during the 1980s, were treated with shot peening. In addition, the stainless steel heads of Wilson Power Chamber metal wood golf clubs were shot peened on their outer surface. Although shot peening treatments have become accepted methods of conditioning the exterior of club heads, a drawback to such treatments is that the peening media may penetrate the club head in thin areas that cannot withstand the repeated, focused impacts.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,487,543 to Funk discloses a shot peened golf club head. The exposed ball striking surface of a golf iron club head is subjected to a very high intensity shot peening to develop an increase in hardness and a compressive stress on the surface. The shot peening is used to work harden the club head face and develop a compressive stress on the surface by cold working.
Despite these developments, there exists a need for an improved golf club head with a compressive layer on the inner surface of the club face. More particularly, there is a need for a golf club head with a compressive layer on the inner surface of the club face that is formed by peening the inner surface.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The invention is related to a metal wood golf club head including a body and a front face having an inner surface and an outer surface, wherein a substantial portion of the inner surface is treated to have a residual compressive stress. The portion of the inner surface is peened by shot peening, laser peening, or abrasive waterjet peening. The portion of the inner surface of the front face has a first thickness before being peened and a second thickness after being peened, and the second thickness is less than the first thickness. The face may be cast or stamped sheet metal. In one embodiment, the portion of the front face is about 0.11 inch thick or less, and in another embodiment the portion of the front face is about 0.10 inch thick or less. The portion may include about 60% or more of the inner surface of the front face in some embodiments, and the portion may include about 80% or more of the inner surface of the front face in other embodiments. A substantial portion of the outer surface of the face is peened, with the substantial portion of the outer surface including about 60% or more of the outer surface in some embodiments and about 80% or more of the outer surface in other embodiments. A portion of the body adjacent to the outer surface may be peened, and the inner surface and a portion of the body adjacent the face may be peened. The face may be formed of titanium, with the body formed of titanium or steel. In another embodiment, the face is formed of steel, and the body is formed of titanium or steel.
The present invention also is related to a method of treating a metal wood golf club head including peening an inner surface of the club head, whereby the inner surface is provided with a residual compressive stress. The club head may include a body and a front face having a face thickness, and the inner surface may include a substantial portion of an inner surface of the front face. The portion may include about 60% or more of the front face in one embodiment, and the portion may include about 80% or more of the front face in another embodiment. The method may further include substantially decreasing the face thickness, and a substantial amount of alpha case may be removed from an inner surface of the front face of the club head. Between about 30 percent and about 90 percent of alpha case, continuous and discontinuous, may be removed from a central region of the inner surface of the front face. The method also may include peening an outer surface of the club head.
The present invention further is related to a front face for a metal wood golf club head, including an inner surface and an outer ball-striking surface, wherein a substantial portion of the inner surface is treated to have a residual compressive stress.
REFERENCES:
patent: 5226652 (1993-07-01), Sato
patent: 5409415 (1995-04-01), Kawanami et al.
patent: 5487543 (1996-01-01), Funk
patent: 5624329 (1997-04-01), Schneebeli
patent: 5779560 (1998-07-01), Buck et al.
patent: 5916383 (1999-06-01), Rokutanda et al.
patent: 6183381 (2001-02-01), Grant et al.
Dwayne D. Arola et al., “Abrasive Waterjet Peening: A New Method of Surface Preparation for Metal Orthopedic Implants,”J. Biomed. Mater. Res.(Appl. Biomater.), vol. 53 (2000): 536-546.
The Theory of Shot Peening, http://www.shotpeening.com/shot_peening_theory.htm, Sep. 14, 2000, 1 page.
William Braisted et al., “Finite element simulation of laser shock peening,”International Journal of Fatigue, vol. 21 (1999): 719-724.
ASM Handbook, vol. 20, Materials Selection and Design, 1997, pp. 399-404.
B. R. Sridhar et al., “Effect of shot peening on the fatigue and fracture behavior of two titanium alloys,”Journal of Materials Science, vol. 31 (1996): 5953-5960.
L. Wagner et al., “Thermomechanical Surface Treatment of Titanium Alloys,”Materials Science Forum, vols. 163-165 (1994): 159-172.
Al-Ti, Jul., 1992, 2 pages.
Mich
Acushnet Company
Duong Thanh
Sewell Paul T.
Swidler Berlin Shereff & Friedman, LLP
LandOfFree
Peen conditioning of titanium metal wood golf club heads does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Peen conditioning of titanium metal wood golf club heads, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Peen conditioning of titanium metal wood golf club heads will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-3039830