Electrical computers and digital processing systems: multicomput – Network computer configuring
Reexamination Certificate
1999-12-29
2003-05-27
Wiley, David (Department: 2142)
Electrical computers and digital processing systems: multicomput
Network computer configuring
C709S221000, C714S037000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06571283
ABSTRACT:
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to data processing systems of the type which include a Server Farm that executes application programs for multiple clients (users); and more particularly, this invention relates to methods for optimizing the “Server Farm size” by balancing Server Farm performance and availability requirements in the above type of data processing systems.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The referenced U.S. Pat. No. 6,334,195 entitled “Estimator Program for Estimating the Availability of an Application Program That Runs in a Cluster of at Least Two Computers” referenced above involves an estimator program to perform method steps for estimating the availability of an application program that rusn on any “server” in a cluster of at least two servers. By “availability of an application program” is meant the probability that at any particular tie instance, at least one of the servers in a cluster (farm) will actually be servicing requests from external workstations able to use the application program.
In one embodiment, the so-called estimator program begins by receiving input parameters which include (i) multiple downtime periods for each computer in the cluster (farm) that occur at respective frequencies due to various downtime sources, and (ii) an application “failover” time period for switching the running of the application program from any one computer to another computer which is operable. From these input parameters, the described estimator program estimates first and second annual stoppage times, then determines the availability of the application program on the cluster of computers which is derived from the sum of the first and second annual stoppage times.
Thus, as discussed, the estimator program of the previously-described invention estimated a first annual stoppage time for the application program due solely to the concurrent stoppage of all of the computers, as a function of the ratio of a single computer virtual downtime period over the single computer virtual time between stops. Then subsequently, the estimator program was used to estimate a second annual stoppage time for the application program, due solely to the switching for running the application program from one computer to another computer as a function of the single virtual stoppage rate and the application failover time period. From this, the estimator program determined the availability of the application program on the cluster of computers by deriving the sum of the first and second annual stoppage times.
The estimator program method was based on the assumption that “application availability” was to be determined from four factors which were:
(i) single-server hardware reliability;
(ii) maintenance, support, and service strategies;
(iii) user application and environment;
(iv) failover or system reconnection mechanism and application recovery mechanism.
The prior estimation parameters which were described in the co-pending application U.S. Ser. No. 08/550,603 did not take into consideration the total number of operating Server Farm clients and the normal single server workload of users involved with each single server. Further, this earlier application did not provide a recommendation or estimate regarding the number of servers required in the Server Farm (or cluster) which would meet the customers' performance and redundancy level requirements, nor did it establish an optimum farm configuration.
The method of the co-pending application U.S. Ser. No. 09/433,926, filed Nov. 19, 1999, now Allowed, entitled “Method for Estimating the Availability of an Operating Server Farm” extended the area of the original method application for Server Farms designed to serve user communities with a required particular number of customers “n”. This method involving the Server Farm size and availability calculations is based on (1) the single server parameters such as (a) the meantime to failure (MTTF), (b) the meantime to repair (MTTR), and (c) the single server application performance benchmarks, and (2) individual customer preferential requirements, involving (a) the total number of Server Farm application users and (b) a desirable redundancy level.
This estimation method for availability uses the following definition of Server Farm availability. This definition is the probability that a Server Farm provides access to applications and data for a particular minimum number of users. As soon as the Server Farm can not serve this particular minimum number of users, it is considered failed. When some of the users have lost connections but can reconnect to other servers and continue to work and the majority of users do not experience any interruptions in their work, the farm is not considered failed, if it can still serve this particular number of users.
A widely used approach to improve a system's availability beyond the availability of a single system is by using Server Farms with redundant servers. In this case, if one of the farm's servers fails, the “unlucky” users connected to this server will lose their connections, but will have an opportunity to reconnect to other servers in the farm and get access to their applications and data. If all of the “unlucky” users get access to their applications and data, the farm is considered “available.” If at least one of the “unlucky” users fails to get access to his/her applications and data, it means that the Server Farm's redundancy was exhausted and the Server Farm is considered failed.
The parameters for MTTF and MTTR can be estimated as indicated in the cited prior U.S. Pat. No. 6,334,196 as single computer virtual time between failures and a single computer virtual downtime period respectively, fro a particular application and user environment.
Therefore, the availability estimation method of the prior application U.S. Ser. No. 09/443,926 allows one to estimate such parameters of the Server Farm as number of servers, Server Farm availability, and Server Farm downtime, based on a set of input data. At the same time, however, this method does not provide any recommendations about optimum combinations of the Server Farm parameters that can be chosen at the Server Farm planning or design stage.
The presently described new method involving the Server Farm size optimization is based on the input data that include single server parameters similar to the prior application U.S. Ser. No. 09/443,926 and at least two new extra parameters: single server cost and the downtime cost. Additionally, this new method includes newly added steps of selecting an optimization parameter, selecting an optimization criterion, and using an optimization technique procedure to find the optimum value of the optimization parameter.
While the present invention may be shown in a preferential embodiment for a Server Farm that uses any workload balancing mechanism, it is not limited thereto, and can be used for any other data processing environment where the definition of the “Server Farm availability” can be applied.
Thus the object of the present invention is to provide a method for optimizing the “Server Farm size” by balancing Server, Farm performance and availability requirements. The method will generate an optimum recommendation for the selected set of input data, the selected optimization criterion and optimization parameter.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In accordance with the present invention, a novel estimator program performs method steps for the Server Farm optimization for a given particular number of clients “n” by balancing Server Farm performance and availability requirements. By the optimization of the Server Farm is herein meant the process of finding the optimum value of the selected optimization parameter that delivers the optimum value (maximum or minimum) for the selected optimization criterion and a given set of input data.
The method of optimization is based on a relationship between two major system attributes, performance and availability, that are “competing” for the same system redundant resources. The purpose of the Server Farm optimization
Kozak Alfred W.
Vaughn, Jr. William C.
Wiley David
LandOfFree
Method for server farm configuration optimization does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Method for server farm configuration optimization, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Method for server farm configuration optimization will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-3047723