Measuring and testing – Vibration – By mechanical waves
Reexamination Certificate
2000-06-01
2002-03-19
Williams, Hezron (Department: 2856)
Measuring and testing
Vibration
By mechanical waves
C073S146000, C073S760000, C073S799000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06357297
ABSTRACT:
TECHNICAL FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention is in the field of railway wheels and, more particularly, relates to preventing shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Recently, railroad transport volume, which is sometimes expressed in terms of railroad freight revenue ton-miles, has been increasing to meet an increasing rail transport demand. As a result, railway cars are hauling ever-heavier average loads. For instance, lightweight aluminum coal cars, which can have maximum gross loads up to 286,000 lbs., have become increasingly common. The wheel loads in such “heavy haul” coal cars are approaching permissible limits, a circumstance which results in lower load safety margins for the wheels of such rail cars.
One serious problem with railway wheels is known as shattered-rim fracture.
Shattered-rim fracture is a phenomenon whereby a rolling contact fatigue crack initiates at an internal defect in the wheel rim subsurface and propagates to ultimately cause substantial damage to the wheel. Left unchecked, the shattered-rim fracture can cause catastrophic failure of the railway wheel and derailment of the rail car. This problem can be exacerbated with increasing wheel speed, unbalanced loads, heavy braking, and other circumstances common in the railway industry.
Given the general increase in freight revenue ton-miles in the rail industry, there is an increasing need to prevent shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels.
OBJECTS AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
It is a general object of the invention to provide a method for preventing catastrophic failure of railway wheels.
Another object of the invention is to provide a method for more effectively preventing shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels.
A further object is to provide a method for testing railway wheels for load suitability during intended usage.
Still another object is to provide a method for grading railway wheels as to load suitability.
Yet another object is to provide methods as characterized above that can be easily and effectively carried out.
Another object is to provide methods of the foregoing types that can be selectively carried out at different safety level rankings.
It is believed that a major cause of the shattered-rim fracture phenomenon is Mode II (in-plane shearing) crack propagation from defects in the rim of the railway wheel. It has now been discovered that shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels can be substantially avoided if the rim of the wheel does not contain defects of a size such as to lead to a Mode II stress intensity factor range (&Dgr;K
II
) at the maximum intended load that is greater than the threshold Mode II stress intensity factor range (&Dgr;K
IITH
) required for cracks to propagate from the defect. The invention makes use of this discovery to prevent shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels. In general, the invention contemplates an analysis of the likelihood of Mode II crack propagation from defects in the rim of a railway wheel. Such analysis may be used to determine the suitability of a railway wheel for carrying a maximum intended load, or alternatively, may be used to determine the maximum suitable load for a railway wheel.
In accordance with a highly preferred embodiment of the invention, a method is provided for more efficiently and effectively preventing shattered-rim fracture in a railway wheel. Generally, the method comprises providing a railway wheel that is expected to be subjected to an intended load, measuring the size of the largest defect within the rim of the wheel, and determining whether the defect size of this defect is below a pre-determined maximum permissible defect size for the intended load. The predetermined maximum defect size is ascertained by evaluating the likelihood of crack propagation from the defect upon subjecting the wheel to the intended load. In accordance with another highly preferred embodiment of the invention, the method for preventing shattered-rim fracture generally comprises the steps of measuring the maximum size of defects in the railway wheel rim, and determining the maximum usage load suitable for said wheel based on a predetermined correspondence between permissible load and defect sizes.
Other objects and advantages of the invention will become apparent upon reading the following detailed description and upon reference to the drawings, in which:
REFERENCES:
patent: 3558876 (1971-01-01), Tillmann
patent: 3596503 (1971-08-01), Gay
patent: 3983745 (1976-10-01), Juusola
patent: 4042273 (1977-08-01), Heller et al.
patent: 4299128 (1981-11-01), Gruber
patent: 4756194 (1988-07-01), Grandpierre et al.
patent: 4781060 (1988-11-01), Berndt
patent: 5793492 (1991-04-01), Vanaki
patent: 5363702 (1994-11-01), Catot et al.
patent: 5899516 (1999-05-01), Fujimura et al.
Sen et al., “Influence of Inclusions and Heat Treatment on Fatigue Strength of Wheel and Axle Steel,”Fatigue Design Symposium(1998).
Danian et al, “The Effects of Cyclic Softening on the Shakedown Limit of Railway Wheel Steel,”International Conference on Mechanical Behaviour of Materials(6th), Kyoto, Japan (1992).
Bo et al., “Railway Wheel Rim Fatigue Break-Down and Relevant Problem,”12thInternational Wheelset Congress Proceedings, Qingdao, China (Sep. 12-25, 1998).
Qian et al., “Fatigue of Railway Wheel and its Damage,”12thInternational Wheelset Congress Proceedings, Qingdao, China (Sep. 21-25, 1998).
Marais, “Wheel Failures on Heavy Haul Freight Wheels Due to Subsurface Defects,”12thInternational Wheelset Congress Proceedings, Qingdao, China (Sep. 21-25, 1998).
Lixian et al., “Study on Rim Fatigue Crack and Prevention,”12thInternational Wheelset Congress Proceedings, Qingdao, China (Sep. 21-25, 1998).
Catot et al., “Contribution to Improve Steel Grades for Wheels for Heavy Freight Traffic,”International Wheelset Congress, Sydney, Australia (Sep. 27 -Oct. 1, 1992).
Sakamoto et al., “Simulation Test on Tread Shelling of Railroad Wheel,”Rail Transportation, 12, pp. 73-78 (1996).
Ekberg et al., “Effects of Imperfections on Fatigue Initiation in Railway Wheels,”Charmec(Oct. 21, 1999).
Gordon et al., “Evaluation of Service-Induced residual Stresses in Railroad Commuter Car Wheels,”Rail Transportation 15, pp. 25-31 (1998).
Magel et al., “Controlling Wheel Shelling,”Railway Track&Structures(Nov. 1997).
Synder, “Shattered Rim Update,”Lab Notes(Jul. 1998).
Diener et al., “Fractures Toughness of R7 Railroad Wheels,”La Metallurgia Italiana, 85(3), pp. 161-167 (1993).
Sakamoto et al., “Fracture Toughness of Medium-High Carbon Steel for Railroad Wheels,”NSF-IMM Symposium on Micromechanic Modeling of Industrial Materials: In Honor of Professor T. Mori's 65th Birthday, Seattle, Washington (Jul. 20-22, 1998).
Stone et al., “Wheel Thermal Damage Limits,”ASME, 1994, pp. 57-63 (1994).
Fujimura Takashi
Makino Taizo
Leydig , Voit & Mayer, Ltd.
Saint-Surin Jacques
Sumitomo Metal Industries, Inc.
Williams Hezron
LandOfFree
Method for preventing shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Method for preventing shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Method for preventing shattered-rim fracture in railway wheels will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2866123