Data processing: financial – business practice – management – or co – Automated electrical financial or business practice or... – Accounting
Reexamination Certificate
1996-07-25
2001-10-30
Millin, Vincent (Department: 2164)
Data processing: financial, business practice, management, or co
Automated electrical financial or business practice or...
Accounting
C705S031000, C705S032000, C705S034000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06311166
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to modelling of accounting systems and more particularly to mechanisms for analyzing the risk that internal controls fail to detect errors that occur in the processing of transactions in an accounting system.
Auditors have the task of determining whether financial statements of a company fairly represent a company's financial position. A problem is gauging how much reliance can be placed on the company's accounting systems. Accounting systems contain internal controls, i.e., procedures that are designed to detect and correct errors and irregularities that may occur during transaction processing. It is an extremely difficult task to anticipate errors that can occur, to determine subsequent effects and to evaluate the effectiveness of controls for detecting errors. Other tasks for which an effective evaluation of internal controls is important are a company's internal audit of its accounting systems, re-engineering of business processes implemented in an accounting system, and review of implementation plans for new accounting systems.
A model-based reasoning system has been under development at Price-Waterhouse Technology Centre in Menlo Park, Calif., as reported in “Modeling accounting systems to support multiple tasks: a progress report,” by Dr. Walter C. Hamscher, as found in the Proceedings of the Tenth National Conference on Artificial Intelligence, San Jose, Calif. July 1992. It described an approach to analyzing failures and their detection by controls without providing a quantitative assessment of the likelihood of detection. A further model-based reasoning system called Comet has formed the basis for further development of the quantitative analysis of accounting systems and their controls. A version called Comet IA without quantitative analysis was first released to licensees in early 1996. The Comet system is used to generate a class of hierarchically structured flowcharts that can be used to model the intended processing of transactions in an accounting system. It is a useful platform for providing a capability for quantitative analysis of control risk. Other systems for constructing flow chart models of accounting systems might also be used as a platform.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
According to the present invention, a method is provided for assessing control risk in a model-based reasoning system used for analyzing financial accounting systems by decomposing and quantifying the risk factors in the model so that the risk factors can be used to determine areas in the accounting system where sufficient control is lacking and to determine which controls are key and thus should be subject to detailed testing. Factors quantified are failure impact risk, failure coverage risk, allowable risk, control detection risk, control strength, control defeat factor, attenuation factor, and control contribution. The present invention is used to enhance a hierarchical flow chart generating system, such as the Comet system, by providing risk analysis operative on a particular class of hierarchically structured flow charts of the type such as generated with a Comet system.
The invention will be better understood upon reference to the following detailed description and the accompanying drawings.
REFERENCES:
patent: 5117356 (1992-05-01), Marks
patent: 5168563 (1992-12-01), Shenoy et al.
patent: 5249300 (1993-09-01), Bachman et al.
patent: 5297150 (1994-03-01), Clark
patent: 5317504 (1994-05-01), Nakayama
patent: 5371680 (1994-12-01), Anno et al.
patent: 5390113 (1995-02-01), Sampson
patent: 5428554 (1995-06-01), Laskoski
patent: 5428619 (1995-06-01), Schwartz et al.
patent: 5448641 (1995-09-01), Pintsov et al.
patent: 5448729 (1995-09-01), Murdock
patent: 5455407 (1995-10-01), Rosen
patent: 5564005 (1996-10-01), Weber et al.
patent: 5568491 (1996-10-01), Beal et al.
patent: 5623534 (1997-04-01), Desai et al.
patent: 5625669 (1997-04-01), McGregor et al.
patent: 5629981 (1997-05-01), Nerlikar
patent: 5638519 (1997-06-01), Haluska
patent: 5680530 (1997-10-01), Selfridge et al.
patent: 5764953 (1998-06-01), Collins et al.
patent: 5768565 (1998-06-01), Matsuda et al.
patent: 92/05485 (1992-04-01), None
Mock T. and Wright A., An exploratory study of auditors' evidential planning judgments, Auditing, V12, 12, p. 39(15).*
Enrado P., Application Watch. (the French...; and Price Waterhouse Technology Centre's knowledge-based systems for financial auditors...), AI Expert, v9, n3, p.48(1).*
Nelson, N.K., Strategies of auditors: Evaluation of Sample results, v14, Issue 1, p.34 (13).*
Auditing Practices Board-UK, Statement of Auditing Standards 300: Auditing and Internal Control Systems and Audit Risks Assessmentsv, V115, Issue 1220, p.127(11).*
Maletta M. and Wright A., Audit Evidence Planning: An Examination of Industry Error Characteristics, Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, V15, N1, Sprg 96.*
Hamscher, W.C., “Modeling Accounting Systems to Support Multiple Tasks: A Progress Report”, in Proc. 10th National Conf. on Artificial Intelligence, San Jose, CA, Jul. 1992.
Nado, B., et al., “The Savile Project”, Price Waterhouse Technology Centre, Oct. 1995.
Chams Mitra M.
Delisio Jefferson L.
Halliday Robert W.
Hamscher Walter C.
Nado Robert A.
Johnson John M.
Kanof Pedro R.
Kaye Scholer LLP
Millin Vincent
Price Waterhouse World Firm Services BV
LandOfFree
Method for analyzing effectiveness of internal controls in a... does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Method for analyzing effectiveness of internal controls in a..., we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Method for analyzing effectiveness of internal controls in a... will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2554035