Liquid purification or separation – Processes – Using magnetic force
Reexamination Certificate
1995-03-21
2001-01-09
Savage, Matthew O. (Department: 1723)
Liquid purification or separation
Processes
Using magnetic force
C210S222000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06171504
ABSTRACT:
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to a fluid treatment device and method for an improved and highly effective magnetic water treatment device that can be mounted on existing pipes which produces a very strong and focused magnetic field.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Magnetic devices were first used in Europe to condition water in the early 1950s after being discovered by a Belgian scientist in 1947. Ventures to sell such devices in the United States initially were not successful in part since the magnets used were of low grade and the claims made by producers regarding the effects of magnetic devices were overstated. The result was bad publicity and considerable skepticism. Since that time, considerable scientific research, engineering research, and anecdotal usage data has concentrated on the effects of magnetism on water and water solutions.
Magnetic Fluid treatment has been shown to suppress the undesirable effects of “scale” and “hard water”. While the exact mechanism for this effect is unknown, it is known that CACO
3
is the hard tenacious scale (calcite) that forms on most piping systems and especially in systems in which water is heated or evaporated. The scale clogs the passages, reduces heat transfer into the water, and reduces the efficiency of the system. It is also the major contributor to the household phenomenon known as “hard water”. Scale itself is not known to be directly affected by a magnetic field.
Some scientific laboratory experiments, which measure CaCO
3
deposits and deposition rates, have confirmed that magnetic fields have an affect under the laboratory conditions. These experiments have established a reduction in CaCO
3
deposits. The presence of non-calcium ions in water, especially those of iron or magnesium, affects scaling rates and properties. The formation of calcite is inversely related to the heating rate and the temperature with aragonite (soft CACO
3
) being more likely to form at high temperatures and heating rates. Magnetism can affect some of the physical properties of water through deaggregation, corrosion rates of some materials in contact with water, and some of the properties of materials in water solutions, especially iron ions.
Many changes to the treatment of water can result in temporary scale reduction but may result in a long term increase in the scaling rate. Most of the successful procedures used for reducing the effects of scale are expensive, technical, and may increase the overall rate of corrosion of the system.
Engineering studies made around the world have shown decreases in scaling and increases in plant efficiency as a result of the use of magnetic devices (generally in connection with procedural changes to eliminate the additional sludge formed).
Engineering studies that show positive results commonly find that: a) the effectiveness of magnetic treatment decreases as the temperature at which the scale forms is reduced; b) a greater percentage of aragonite in scale is formed from magnetically exposed water; and c) the scale which forms after exposure to magnetism is softer and easier to remove.
Literally hundreds of industrial, commercial, private and public service providers in the United States have used and profited from magnetic water treatment. Despite their inability to scientifically explain the phenomenon, authors publishing for the American Chemical Society even classify it as a “scale control technique” and identify several manufacturers of devices useful for such treatment. Popular Mechanics in June 1992 reports on many successful applications of magnetic water treatment devices in both commercial and industrial settings. Many of the users to which they allude are very small businesses, not much larger than single home situations.
Presently, scientists dispute the details of the effects of magnetic devices on water and water impurities, but acknowledge that the phenomenon exists and that it merits further study. A model for understanding the phenomena is based on recognizing that magnetic fields impose forces on moving electric charges (ions in the water) and magnetic dipoles (molecular sized magnets). Forces acting on any matter can change its energy state. Water molecules have magnetic moments and are temporarily affected by passing through a magnetic field. This molecular change will relax over time. Most users of magnetic water conditioning devices are more concerned with the effect of the magnetic field of the device on ions. The forces caused by the magnet can provide the activation energy needed by the ions to form new molecular structures and break some other structures. The new structures essentially suspend the impurities in the water in a way that reduces their tendency to precipitate out of solution to form scale on pipes and in devices such as heaters or boiler tubes.
Clearly, the types of impurities in the water are going to affect the type response a system has to exposure to a magnetic device. Because one can not predict what impurities exist in a specific water system, one can not predict the exact results of putting the magnetic water conditioning devices on that system.
However if a system has suffered from build up of scale, installation of the magnetic devices probably will result in a significant reduction in new scaling and generally a removal of the old scale. Scale reduces heat transfer and therefore raises energy costs and often causes premature heating element failure. To keep scale from accumulating, many operators use chemicals. In such systems, the use of magnetic water conditioning can result in a reduction in the amount of chemical used.
Many engineers have used magnetic water treatment successfully to reduce scaling, improve efficiency, and prolong equipment life. A broad range of conditions seems susceptible to successful application of magnetic water treatment devices. Use in processes similar to those which were successful is likely to produce equivalent results and use in systems that are only marginally different from the known successes is a low risk venture.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PRIOR ART
Applicant is aware of the following U.S. Pat. Nos. concerning
magnetic water treatment.
U.S. Pat. No.
Issue Date
Inventor
Title
2,652,925
09-22-1953
Vermeiren
MAGNETIC
TREATMENT
DEVICE FOR
LIQUIDS
4,265,754
05-05-1981
Menold
WATER TREATING
APPARATUS AND
METHODS
4,265,755
05-05-1981
Zimmerman
MAGNETIC FLUID
TREATING UNIT
4,265,756
05-05-1981
Schiesser
CHANGE DEVICE FOR
SIEVES FOR
FILTERING PLASTIC
MATERIALS
4,711,271
12-08-1987
Weisenbarger
MAGNETIC FLUID
CONDITIONER
4,836,932
06-06-1989
Walsh
WATER TREATMENT
USING FINE
PARTICLE SUPER
MAGNETS
5,113,751
05-19-1992
Holcomb
BEVERAGE BREWING
SYSTEM
5,200,071
04-06-1993
Spiegel
TRANSLATING
MAGNETIC FIELD
TREATMENT DEVICE
5,227,683
07-13-1993
Clair
MAGNET ASSEMBLY
WITH
CONCENTRATOR FOR
PROVIDING FLUX
LINES
PERPENDICULAR TO
FLUID FLOW
DIRECTION WITHIN
STEEL PIPE
5,238,558
08-24-1993
Curtis
MAGNETO-
HYDRODYNAMIC
FLUID TREATMENT
SYSTEM
5,296,141
03-22-1994
Ellison
MAGNETIC WATER
CONDITIONER
5,378,362
01-03-1995
Schoepe
APPARATUS FOR
MAGNETICALLY
TREATING WATER
PAPERS
Title
Author
MAGNETIC WATER TREATMENT
Merle Henkenius
EFFECTIVENESS OF MAGNETIC WATER
David Hasson and
TREATMENT IN SUPPRESSING CaCO
3
Dan Bramson
SCALE DEPOSITION
Vermeiren U.S. Pat. No. 2,652,925 teaches a treatment device which produces a magnetic field and a passage for the liquid to be treated.
Menold U.S. Pat. No. 4,265,754 provides an apparatus for treating fresh water by producing a magnetic field in proximity to a flow of water within a water conduit.
Zimmerman U.S. Pat. No. 4,265,755 provides a magnetic water treating device within a conduit. This device provides easy assembly without adversely affecting the ultimate functional capability of the overall unit.
Schiesser U.S. Pat. No. 4,265,756 provides a change device for sieves used for filtering plastic materials. The sieves can be changed with this device without interrupting the transport of the material which is being processed.
Weisenbarger U.S. Pat. No. 4,711,271 provides a magnetic fluid conditio
Dougherty & Clements LLP
Savage Matthew O.
LandOfFree
Magnetic water conditioner does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Magnetic water conditioner, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Magnetic water conditioner will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2441463