Fire extinguishers – Sprinkler heads
Reexamination Certificate
2000-03-16
2002-01-08
Scherbel, David A. (Department: 3752)
Fire extinguishers
Sprinkler heads
C169S038000, C169S040000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06336509
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Early suppression fast response (“ESFR”) sprinklers are a well known and well defined class of ceiling fire sprinklers. ESFR sprinklers were developed in the 1980's by Factory Mutual Research Corporation (“FM”) with the assistance of certain sprinkler manufacturers in an effort to provide improved fire protection against certain high-challenge fire hazards. According to FM, ESFR sprinklers combine fast response with greater supplied and actually delivered water densities for greater fire suppression capability. Previous sprinklers (standard sprinklers) provided protection by merely keeping such fires under control. Ultimately the initial fuel source would deplete itself or other fire fighting equipment would have to be brought to the scene to extinguish the fire.
The performance requirements of ESFR sprinklers are set forth in Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. (“UL”) STANDARD FOR EARLY-SUPPRESSION FAST-RESPONSE SPRINKLERS UL 1767. This standard was first published in 1990. Factory Mutual Research Corporation (“Factory Mutual” or “FM”) also has an Approval Standard For Early Suppression—Fast Response (ESFR) Automatic Sprinklers, Class Number 2008. The current ESFR standards and all earlier ESFR standards of either organization are incorporated by reference herein in their entirety.
Requirements for the installation and use of ESFR sprinklers are included in various standards of the National Fire Protection Association including the Standard for the Installation of Sprinkler Systems, NFPA 13; the Standard for General Storage, NFPA 231; and the Standard for Rack Storage of Materials, NFPA 231c. The current and earlier editions of these standards to the extent that they pertain to ESFR sprinklers are incorporated by reference herein. Installation and use requirements for ESFR sprinklers are also given Loss Prevention Data sheets 2-2, “EARLY SUPPRESSION FAST RESPONSE SPRINKLERS”,
Factory Mutual System,
Factory Mutual Engineering Corp., 1987, which is also incorporated by reference herein. Loss Prevention Data sheets 2-8 N, “Installation of Sprinkler Systems”,
Factory Mutual System,
Factory Mutual Engineering Corp., 1989, presents other installation and use requirements for ESFR and other sprinklers generally which are not presented in Loss Prevention Data sheets 2-2 and is also incorporated herein.
The standards specify the construction, performance, installation and operation of ESFR sprinklers with significant particularity. For example, the discharge coefficient (or “K” factor) of an ESFR sprinkler is nominally 14 and must be within the range of 13.5-14.5, where the discharge coefficient is calculated by dividing the flow of water in gallons per minute through the sprinkler by the square root of the pressure of water supplied to the sprinkler in pounds per square inch gauge. Ordinary or standard sprinklers are considered to have response time indices (“RTI”) of 100 meter
½
second
½
(“m
½
sec
½
”) or more although the response time indices actually reported for these sprinklers have all exceeded 100 m
½
sec
½
. One special class of faster operating sprinklers exists with response time indices between 50 and 80 m
½
sec
½
. Existing ESFR sprinklers must exhibit response time indices of less than 40 m
½
sec
½
. The installation and use standards further require, among other things, that a minimum operating pressure of 50 psi be provided to ESFR sprinklers.
ESFR sprinklers were originally designed to suppress fires in warehouses with thirty-foot ceilings where flammable stock such as certain plastics is piled up to twenty-five feet high in racks. In many instances, available water supplies are not capable of providing a minimum operating pressure of 50 psi to thirty-foot high sprinklers. In such cases, a supplemental pump is needed to boost water pressure before ESFR sprinklers can be used. The cost of providing an auxiliary pump can be significant. For example, in protecting a 40,000 square foot building with ESFR sprinklers, it is estimated that the cost of providing an auxiliary pump can represent about twenty-five (25) percent of the entire cost of the installed sprinkler system. In certain installations, a second, back-up pump may be needed. If comparable protection might be provided at pressures below the current 50 psig minimum required pressured for ESFR sprinklers, the need for a pump might be avoided. In instances where a pump would be required in any event, lower pressure requirements may permit the use of a lower capacity, less expensive pump or the use of the same pump with smaller diameter, higher friction but less expensive supply lines. Each of these three possible options could provide significant savings in installation costs of ESFR sprinklers.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In one aspect the invention is a low pressure fast response bulb sprinkler comprising a generally tubular body having an inlet end, an opposing discharge end and an internal passageway extending between the inlet and discharge ends with a K factor greater than 16 where the K factor equals the flow of water in gallons per minute through the internal passageway divided by the square root of the pressure of water fed into the internal passageway in pounds per square inch gauge; a deflector coupled with the tubular body and spaced from and generally aligned with the discharge end of the internal passageway so as to be impacted by a flow of water issuing from the discharge end of the passageway upon activation of the sprinkler, the deflector being configured and positioned to deflect the flow of water generally radially outwardly all around the sprinkler; a closure releasably positioned at the discharge end of the tubular body so as to close the internal passageway; and a heat responsive trigger at least including a frangible liquid containing glass bulb mounted to releasably retain the closure at the discharge end of the tubular body, the glass bulb having a response time index of less than 100 meter
½
sec
½
(m
½
sec
½
).
REFERENCES:
patent: 3525402 (1970-08-01), Hattori
patent: 3682251 (1972-08-01), Livingston
patent: 3722596 (1973-03-01), Livingston
patent: 3768736 (1973-10-01), Cox
patent: 3811511 (1974-05-01), McCulloch
patent: 3888313 (1975-06-01), Freeman
patent: 3904126 (1975-09-01), Allard
patent: 4091873 (1978-05-01), Werner
patent: 4099675 (1978-07-01), Wohler et al.
patent: 4136740 (1979-01-01), Groos et al.
patent: 4279309 (1981-07-01), Fischer et al.
patent: 4359097 (1982-11-01), Claussen
patent: 4405018 (1983-09-01), Fischer
patent: 4580729 (1986-04-01), Pounder
patent: 4657085 (1987-04-01), Jacobsen
patent: 4800961 (1989-01-01), Klein
patent: 4893679 (1990-01-01), Martin et al.
patent: 4901799 (1990-02-01), Pepi et al.
patent: 4930578 (1990-06-01), Barnett et al.
patent: 5036923 (1991-08-01), Shea
patent: 5094298 (1992-03-01), Polan
patent: 5366022 (1994-11-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5579846 (1996-12-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5584344 (1996-12-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5609211 (1997-03-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5622225 (1997-04-01), Sundholm
patent: 5664630 (1997-09-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5829532 (1998-11-01), Meyer et al.
patent: 5853215 (1998-12-01), Lowery
Underwriters Laboratories, Inc., UL 1767, “Standard for Safety, Early-Suppression Fast-Response Sprinklers”, First Edition, Feb., 1990.
Factory Mutual Engineering Corp., “Loss Prevention Data, 2-2”, “Early Suppression Fast Response Sprinklers”, Apr., 1987.
Factory Mutual Research, “Approval Standard, Early Suppression Fast Response Automatic Sprinklers”, Jun., 1986.
“Automatic” Sprinkler Corporation of America product sheets entitled “Automatic ESFR Glass Bulb Sprinkler”, Feb., 1988, (pp. J 5.3, J 5.4).
ASCOA Fire Systems data sheets entitled, “Automatic ESFR Glass Bulb Sprinkler”, Mar., 1992, (pp. 1.1, 1.2).
Grinnell Corporation data sheets entitled “Early Suppression Fast Response Sprinklers/Model ESFR-1 Pendent, 14.3 K-Factor”, Apr., 1988.
Reliable Automatic Sprinkler product announcement,
Golinveaux James E.
Meyer Stephen J.
Polan George S.
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld L.L.P.
Central Sprinkler Corporation
Hwu Davis
Scherbel David A.
LandOfFree
Low pressure fast response bulb sprinklers does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Low pressure fast response bulb sprinklers, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Low pressure fast response bulb sprinklers will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2854085