Sheet metal container making – Method – Assembling receptacle with closure
Reexamination Certificate
2005-02-01
2005-02-01
Larson, Lowell A. (Department: 3725)
Sheet metal container making
Method
Assembling receptacle with closure
C413S031000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06848875
ABSTRACT:
A can end comprising a peripheral cover hook, a chuck wall dependent from a first point on the interior of the cover hook, an outwardly concave annular reinforcing bead extending radially inwards from a second point on the interior of the chuck wall, and a central panel supported by an inner portion of the reinforcing bead, characterized in that, a line connecting the first point and the second point is inclined to an axis perpendicular to the exterior of the central panel at an angle between 30° and 60°.
REFERENCES:
patent: 3023927 (1962-03-01), Ehman
patent: 3526486 (1970-09-01), Smith et al.
patent: 3843014 (1974-10-01), Cospen et al.
patent: 3967752 (1976-07-01), Cudzik
patent: 4015744 (1977-04-01), Brown
patent: 4024981 (1977-05-01), Brown
patent: 4093102 (1978-06-01), Kraska
patent: 4148410 (1979-04-01), Brown
patent: 4150765 (1979-04-01), Mazurek
patent: 4210257 (1980-07-01), Radtke
patent: 4217843 (1980-08-01), Kraska
patent: 4276993 (1981-07-01), Hasegawa
patent: 4286728 (1981-09-01), Fraze et al.
patent: 4365724 (1982-12-01), Walden
patent: 4402421 (1983-09-01), Ruemer, Jr.
patent: 4448322 (1984-05-01), Kraska
patent: D279265 (1985-06-01), Turner et al.
patent: 4559801 (1985-12-01), Smith et al.
patent: 4578007 (1986-03-01), Diekhoff
patent: 4606472 (1986-08-01), Taube et al.
patent: D285661 (1986-09-01), Brownbill
patent: 4674649 (1987-06-01), Pavely
patent: 4681238 (1987-07-01), Sanchez
patent: 4685582 (1987-08-01), Pulciani et al.
patent: 4716755 (1988-01-01), Bulso, Jr. et al.
patent: 4782594 (1988-11-01), Porucznik et al.
patent: 4808052 (1989-02-01), Bulso, Jr. et al.
patent: 4809861 (1989-03-01), Wilkinson et al.
patent: D300608 (1989-04-01), Taylor et al.
patent: D304302 (1989-10-01), Dalli et al.
patent: 4893725 (1990-01-01), Ball et al.
patent: 4930658 (1990-06-01), McEldowney
patent: 5046637 (1991-09-01), Kysh
patent: 5049019 (1991-09-01), Franek et al.
patent: 5064087 (1991-11-01), Koch
patent: 5129541 (1992-07-01), Voigt et al.
patent: 5143504 (1992-09-01), Braakman
patent: D337521 (1993-07-01), McNulty
patent: 5252019 (1993-10-01), Saunders et al.
patent: D347172 (1994-05-01), Heynen et al.
patent: 5356256 (1994-10-01), Turner et al.
patent: D352898 (1994-11-01), Vacher
patent: 5494184 (1996-02-01), Noguchi et al.
patent: 5582319 (1996-12-01), Heyes et al.
patent: 5839869 (1998-11-01), Moran et al.
patent: D406236 (1999-03-01), Brifcani et al.
patent: 5911551 (1999-06-01), Moran
patent: 5957647 (1999-09-01), Hinton
patent: 5971259 (1999-10-01), Bacon
patent: 6024239 (2000-02-01), Turner et al.
patent: 6065634 (2000-05-01), Brifcani et al.
patent: 6089072 (2000-07-01), Fields
patent: 92 11 788.0 (1993-01-01), None
patent: 0 153 115 (1985-08-01), None
patent: 0 153 115 (1985-08-01), None
patent: 0 340 955 (1989-11-01), None
patent: 1444470 (1976-07-01), None
patent: 2 143 202 (1985-02-01), None
patent: 2 196 891 (1988-05-01), None
patent: 2 218 024 (1989-11-01), None
patent: 57-117323 (1982-07-01), None
patent: 01167050 (1989-06-01), None
patent: WO 9317864 (1993-09-01), None
United States Brewers Association, Inc., “Brewing Industry Recommended Can Specifications Manual,” pp. 1-1, 2-1, and 3-2, Washington, DC, May 1983.
Society of Soft Drink Technologists, “Beverage Can, End, & Double Seam Dimensional Specifications,” pp. 2, 1B-2 to 5, Hartfield, VA, Fourth Revision, Aug. 1993.
Beverage Can “Mini Seams” by Pete Moran published by CMB Engineering Group plc contents page, pp. 3 through 30 and figures, published mid-1980s.
“Modern Beverage Can Double Seaming” published by Continental Beverage Packaging Cover page and 2 unnumbered pages, undated.
“Aluminium canstock” The Canmaker, Jan. 1994 pp. 38 through 43.
Notice of Opposition to a European Patent 96908205.6/828,663 Opposed by American National Can Company (Facts and Arguments), Dec. 12, 1999, 21 pages.
Letter From Ismay Ratliff Of Crown Cork & Seal To EPO, Apr. 19, 2001, One Page, Enclosing Patentee's Observations And Amendments In Response To The Opposition, 9 pages, and Summary of Main and Auxiliary Requests, Main Request, and Auxiliary Requests 1, 2, and 3, 14 pages.
Letter From PRB Lawrence of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, Nov. 6, 2001, Nine Pages, Beginning, “The opponent that the patentee has not responded to the detailed argumentation . . . ” with three pages of graphics and with EPO Cover Page dated Nov. 15, 2001.
Letter From PRB Lawrence of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, Nov. 27, 2001, Two Pages, beginning, “I refer to the final paragraph of page 9 of my comments of 6thNov. and . . . ” with three page attachment having graphics and with EPO Cover Page dated Dec. 5, 2001.
Letter from Ismay Ratliff of Crown Cork & Seal to EPO, Nov. 28, 2001, One Page, beginning, “I refer to the letter from the Opponent of Nov. 6, 2001”.
Letter From PRB Lawrence Of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, Dec. 11, 2001, One Page, Beginning “I not the patentee's comments of Nov. 28”.
Letter from Ismay Ratliff of Crown Cork & Seal to EPO, Jan. 18, 2002, One Page, beginning, “I refer to the communications of Nov. 15, 2001, Dec. 5, 2001, Jan. 7, 2002 . . . ”.
Letter from Ismay Ratliff of Crown Cork & Seal to EPO, Mar. 18, 2002, Three Pages, beginning “Further to my letter of Jan. 18, 2002, I enclose further submissions in response to the Opponent's letters of Nov.15, Nov. 27, and Dec. 11, 2001” with 10 pages of claims including Main Request, Auxiliary Request, and Auxiliary Request 2.
Letter From PRB Lawrence Of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, May 2, 2002, 7 Pages, Beginning, “I maintain all the objections in the original opposition and in the submission of the Nov. 6 and 27, 2001 . . . ” with cover page from EPO dated May 16, 2002.
Letter from Ismay Ratliff of Crown Cork & Seal to EPO, Jul. 4, 2002, Four Pages, Beginning, “This is in response to the Opponents' further submission dated May 2, 2002.”.
Summons to Attend Oral Proceedings Pursuant to Rule 71 (1) EPC, Oct. 21, 2001, 7 pages.
Letter from PRB Lawrence of Gill Jennings & Every, Jun. 24, 2002, with Affidavit of Thomas T. Tung with Attachments A thru D, Jun. 14, 2002.
Letter from PRB Lawrence of Gill Jennings & Every, Jul. 19, 2002, with Extracts of the Pechiney Annual REport 1989, 5 pages, Triangle Industries, Inc., Annual Report, 1987, 2 pages.
Final Submission by the EP patentee in the EPO opposition proceeding: European Patent Application No. 96908205.6 (now European Patent No. 0 828 663), CarnaudMetalbox, Plc, Opposition by American National Can Company, (Copy), Feb. 11, 2003, with Attachments, 38 pages.
Final submissions by the EP opponent in the EPO opposition proceeding: European Patent Application No. 96908205.6-2308/0828663, CarnaudMetalbox Plc, (Copy), Feb. 18, 2003, with Attachments, Affidavit by John Davy, Statement of Facts of John Zappa, 53 pages.
Letter From PRB Lawrence Of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, Feb. 19, 2003, One Page, beeginning, “There are two points supplementary to my letter of Feb. 18. . . ”.
Letter From PRB Lawrence Of Gill Jennings & Every To EPO, Feb. 20, 2003, Two Pages, Beginning We Have Been Considering Further The Recent Assertion By The Patentee About The Alleged Non-Enabling Nature . . . :.
Interlocutory Decision of the Opposition Division of the European Patent Office in Respect of the EP Patent No. 0828663, (Copy), May 5, 2003, 25 pages.
Grounds of Appeal against the Interlocutory Decision by the Opposition Division, (Copy), filed by EP patentee, Sep. 2, 2003, European Patent No. 0 828 663 (Formerly European Patent Application No. 96908205.6) CarnaudMetalbox Plc and CarnmaudMetalbox SA Appeal against the Interlocutory Decision of the Opposition Division, May 5, 2003, with attached copies of Main Request, and Auxiliary Request 1 thru 8, 32 pages.
Grounds of Appeal against the Interlocutory Decision by the Opposition Division, (Confirmation), filed by EP opponent, S
Brifcani Mouayed Mamdooh
Hinton Peter James
Kysh Mark Christopher
Crown Cork & Seal Technologies Corporation
Larson Lowell A.
LandOfFree
Can end and method for fixing the same to a can body does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Can end and method for fixing the same to a can body, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Can end and method for fixing the same to a can body will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-3513252