Surgery – Radioactive substance applied to body for therapy
Reexamination Certificate
1999-08-17
2002-05-14
Lacyk, John P. (Department: 3736)
Surgery
Radioactive substance applied to body for therapy
Reexamination Certificate
active
06387034
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND
1. Field of the Inventions
The inventions are related to brachytherapy in general and are specifically related to the placement and dosage of radioactive materials for brachytherapy.
2. Related Art
Brachytherapy is a type of radiation therapy that involves the placement of radioactive sources (referred to herein as “seeds”) either in tumors (interstitial implants) or near tumors (intracavity therapy and/or mold therapy). In this treatment approach, radiation from the radioactive sources is emitted outward and is limited to short distances. Thus, unlike external beam radiotherapy, where radiation must traverse normal tissue in order to reach the tumor, brachytherapy is much more localized and therefore reduces radiation exposure to normal tissue while allowing a higher radiation dose as compared to external beam radiotherapy. Brachytherapy has become increasingly popular for the treatment of early-stage prostate carcinoma; therefore, the present inventions will be discussed with reference to the treatment of a prostate tumor. However, those of skill in the art will recognize that the present inventions are not limited to treatment of prostate tumors and that many other uses of the inventions are possible.
In the past, a major limitation to the use of radioactive seed implants was the difficulty of accurately placing the seeds, which may number from approximately 40-100, in a designated geometric pattern. However, with the advent of imaging devices such as transrectal ultrasound (TRUS), it has become possible to image both the prostate and the radioactive seeds. This in turn allows a radiation oncologist greater control in the placement of seeds than had been possible. Seed implantation is commonly performed with a template
300
(a plastic slab with a rectangular grid of holes in it as shown in FIG.
3
), which is attached to a TRUS transducer
410
and mounted on a transperineal implantation device
400
as shown in FIG.
4
. The TRUS transducer
410
transmits images to a dedicated display unit. A series of transverse images are taken through the prostate, and the TRUS unit displays the template grid superimposed on the prostate image. Needles inserted at the appropriate grid positions enable seed placement in the target at planned locations.
The existence of a suitable procedure for accurately placing seeds raises a second issue: determining the optimal placement (also referred to as the configuration) of the seeds. The placement of seeds should be chosen to satisfy two criteria: a) the sufficiency of the radioactive dose received by the tumor; and b) the minimization of the radioactive dose received by surrounding healthy tissue. The large number of potential configurations means only a small fraction of configurations can be investigated manually.
A number of prior art techniques used to determine seed configurations have been used in the past, including the Manchester Paterson-Parker system, the Quimby system and the Paris system. One problem with these known methods is that they take a large amount of time (on the order of four hours or more) to perform. Thus, treatment strategies devised using these methods are typically generated in a simulation session several days (or weeks) before placement is to be performed. Unfortunately, it is often the case that the position of the diseased organ in the operating room differs from the position of the organ for which the treatment plan was intended. In such cases, it may be necessary to change the plan in the operating room. What is needed is a method and apparatus for quickly (i.e., within minutes) calculating a good brachytherapy treatment plan.
SUMMARY
The aforementioned need is met to a great extent by the present invention which provides an integer linear programming model for the placement of seeds and several techniques for finding optimized solutions for seed placement problems based on the model. The model uses binary (referred to herein as “0/1”) indicator variables to represent the placement or non-placement of seeds in a predetermined three-dimensional grid of potential seed locations. In preferred embodiments, the three dimensional grid of potential locations corresponds to the intersections of the rectangular grid of holes of the template discussed above with each of a number of parallel “cuts” of the tumor and surrounding tissue imaged by an imaging device such as a TRUS or CT scanner. The images generated by the imaging device are discretized into a number of image points at a granularity which may or may not be equal to the granularity of the template. The dose delivered to each image point is modeled as a linear combination of the indicator variables. A system of linear constraints is imposed to attempt to keep the dose level at each image point within specified bounds. Branch-and-bound and genetic algorithms are provided to find optimized solutions based on the model. The branch-and-bound and genetic methods may either maximize the sum of rewards associated with achieving the specified bounds or minimize the sum of penalties associated with deviating from the desired bounds.
REFERENCES:
patent: 5205289 (1993-04-01), Hardy et al.
patent: 6095975 (2000-08-01), Silvern
Lee, Eva K., Slides from “Integer Programming Strategies In Solving Large—Scale Set Partition/Covering Problems”, Given to Lucent Technologies, 1996.
Lee, Eva K., Talk on “Computational Experience with a General Purpose Mixed 0/1 Integer Programming Solver MIPSOL”, Given at INFORMS Conference, May 1997.
Lightsey, Ed, “Theragenics: The Shooting Star of Georgia Stocks in '97 More Importantly, TheraSeed Offers New Hope for Men With Prostate Cancer”, Health Care—Stocks, Georgia Trend, Nov. 1997.
Gallagher, Richard J., et al, “Mixed Integer Programming Optimization Models for Brachytherapy Treatment Planning”, Daniel R. Masys, Ed., Proceedings of the 1997 American Medical Informatics Association Annual Fall Symposium, pp. 278-282, Oct. 25, 1997.
Lee, Eva K. et al., “Treatment Planning for Brachytherapy: An Integer Programming Model, Two Computational Approaches and Experiments on Permanent Prostate Implant Planning”, Physics in Medicine and Biology, pp. 145-165, May 1998.
Georia Tech Research Corporation
Lacyk John P.
Szmal Brian
Thomas Kayden Horstemeyer & Risley LLP
LandOfFree
Brachytherapy treatment planning method and apparatus does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Brachytherapy treatment planning method and apparatus, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Brachytherapy treatment planning method and apparatus will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2881230