X-ray or gamma ray systems or devices – Specific application – Absorption
Reexamination Certificate
2000-04-21
2002-05-21
Kim, Robert H. (Department: 2876)
X-ray or gamma ray systems or devices
Specific application
Absorption
C378S041000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06393095
ABSTRACT:
PRIORITY CLAIM
This application claims priority to British Patent Application No. 9909163.9, filed Apr. 21, 1999.
This invention relates to a method of automatic defect detection for production assemblies.
BACKGROUND TO THE INVENTION
The technique of producing stereoscopic images, whether in visible light or in X-rays, is well known. A stereoscopic image consists of a left and a right perspective view of a given object or scene. When such images are then correctly aligned and presented to a human observer, they provide a full 3-D (binocular stereoscopic) image of the scene.
In general, each of the perspective images contains information taken from slightly different viewpoints. Consequently, the image of a particular feature of an object will be in a slightly different position in each of the perspective views. The physical measurement of this difference is known as binocular parallax or simply parallax.
With stereoscopic images prepared in visual light, a range image can be extracted from the stereoscopic pair if the parallax information is known and the geometrical and optical parameters of the stereoscopic arrangement are also known.
Production of a pair of shadowgraph stereoscopic images using an X-ray source is also known and is described, for example, in European Patent No. 610081. The resulting stereoscopic pair of images can be processed as described in that Patent to produce a 2½D image of an object being viewed.
Whilst, however, such a technique is extremely useful in security situations such as the checking of baggage at airports, such an arrangement does not lend itself to being used to check a production sample against a perfect sample, often known as the “golden sample”. Thus, such an arrangement would be very time consuming and would be a processor intensive task. At best, such an arrangement could be used to make random checks rather than to check each production sample and would, therefore, not be a significant improvement over and above typical manual random checks which are made at the moment.
The problem of checking production samples is particularly acute when the production sample involves an electronic assembly. Thus, electronic assemblies are rapidly increasing in complexity whilst, at the same time, decreasing in size. New packaging technologies such as ball grid arrays (devices with their electrical contacts arranged in a dense grid format under the component) and embedded components do not lend themselves to traditional visual inspection techniques since their contacts are both situated under the device and often encapsulated.
An obvious solution and one which has been employed for many years is to employ simple X-ray inspection techniques. However, such simple X-ray inspection techniques do not involve stereoscopic images and only produce a two dimensional shadowgraph. Such shadowgraph images do not contain any depth information and their use is therefore limited.
To overcome this, the object has been manipulated in front of a continuous X-ray source and viewed via a fluorescent screen from many different angles. An operator can then derive his own spacial interpretation of the features and make a decision on the viability of the product. This technique, although versatile, is slow and so is not suitable for in-line inspection and does not lend itself to automation. Also, of course, because the inspection is slow, it would only be possible to examine random production samples rather than to examine all production samples.
It is, therefore, an object of the present invention to provide a detection system which can lend itself to automation and which can be conducted relatively quickly so that all production samples can be checked.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
According to the invention, a pair of stereoscopic images of an object are produced, one image is subtracted from the other, and the resulting two dimensional image is then checked against and compared with a similar two dimensional image (the golden image) which has been produced in an identical manner using a known perfect sample (the golden sample).
As a result, the overall three dimensional inspection process is now reduced to a simple comparison of a 2D pattern from the sample under test with the corresponding 2D golden pattern for a known perfect sample. Such a comparison can readily be automated, can be quick and, therefore, is applicable in industrial terms to the checking of each sample on a production line. Thus, for example, the 2D pattern can be considered to be a scanned digital signal and it is relatively simple to compare such a digital signal from one sample with that from the golden sample. If they are identical, then the scanned sample corresponds accurately to the golden sample and if they are not identical then it differs and may therefore be unacceptable as a production product.
Generally speaking, when one is dealing with electronic assemblies, it will be necessary to use X-rays to check the sample since often one will need to view areas which are totally enclosed or encapsulated. In such a case, it is highly convenient that the X-ray images be produced using two parallel curtains of X-rays. The object under test can then be moved on a conveying source such as a conveying belt through and past the two curtains, preferably a pair of diverging thin curtain beams of X-rays, with line detectors beneath the conveying means used to produce the two images. Such a technique is described, for example, in European patent application No. 87308517.9, Serial No. 261 984 and reference is made to that application and its contents are incorporated herein as an example to show how X-ray stereoscopic pairs can be obtained.
The invention, however, is not limited to the use of X-ray images but can just as easily be applied to images produced by visible light or infra-red where only visible surface effects are being checked. Equally, the invention is applicable to ultra-sound images and here, of course, such ultrasound images can be useful in detecting areas which are visually hidden just as with X-rays.
The checking of the golden 2D image pattern relative the 2D image pattern produced from the sample under test can readily be automated by suitable processing techniques. For example, once the two stereoscopic images have been produced, they can be viewed in digital form and one image subtracted from the other to give a resulting digital 2D image. In turn, that resulting digital 2D image can then be checked with the golden 2D image very rapidly by means of a processor and any faults in the original production sample will immediately become apparent because of a mismatch in the two images. On the other hand, if the two images correspond identically, it can be assumed that the sample under test is identical with the golden sample and so the sample under test can be passed as fit for use.
Processors are readily available to conduct this subtraction and compare the resulting 2D pattern with that of the golden image at very high speeds which means that it is then readily possible for one to check the whole of a production output of, say, a mobile telephone production line so that full three dimension external and internal inspection of the manufactured article is possible without the necessity for human intervention.
REFERENCES:
patent: 4475104 (1984-10-01), Shen
patent: 4558359 (1985-12-01), Kuperman et al.
patent: 4573191 (1986-02-01), Kidode et al.
patent: 4598369 (1986-07-01), Wang et al.
patent: 4682160 (1987-07-01), Beckwith Jr.
patent: 4704627 (1987-11-01), Yuyama et al.
patent: 4737921 (1988-04-01), Goldwassen et al.
patent: 4837616 (1989-06-01), Kasano et al.
patent: 4879668 (1989-11-01), Cline et al.
patent: 4985854 (1991-01-01), Wittenburg
patent: 5051904 (1991-09-01), Griffith
patent: 5155750 (1992-10-01), Klynn et al.
patent: 5190000 (1993-03-01), Lipton et al.
patent: 5200819 (1993-04-01), Nudelman et al.
patent: 5229935 (1993-07-01), Yamagishi et al.
patent: 5233639 (1993-09-01), Marks
patent: 6061476 (2000-05-01), Nichani
patent: 0 261 984 (1987-09-01), None
patent: 873085
Fredrikson & Byron , P.A.
Kiknadze Irakli
Kim Robert H.
The Nottingham Trent University
LandOfFree
Automatic defect detection does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Automatic defect detection, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Automatic defect detection will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2840098