Hazardous or toxic waste destruction or containment – Containment – Solidification – vitrification – or cementation
Reexamination Certificate
1999-05-28
2002-06-04
Griffin, Steven P. (Department: 1754)
Hazardous or toxic waste destruction or containment
Containment
Solidification, vitrification, or cementation
C210S749000
Reexamination Certificate
active
06399850
ABSTRACT:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
The invention relates to neutralization of aldehyde for the purpose of complying with waste disposal requirements established by federal and state environmental protection agencies.
2. Description of Related Art
Waste disposal of aldehydes has become increasingly more difficult over the years. Treatment of wastes containing a certain amount of aldehyde prior to placement of the waste into the environment is required by law. The extent of such treatment may vary depending upon the location of where the waste is generated and the stringency of the environmental standards in that area. For example, waste containing aldehyde may be classified as a hazardous waste in California under 22 C
AL
. C
ODE
R
EGS
.,
TTT
. 22, §66696. Formaldehyde also may be considered a hazardous waste on the federal level under 40 C.F.R. §261.33(e) if it is a commercial chemical product (e.g., pure technical grade formaldehyde or formaldehyde is the sole active ingredient of the product that is to be disposed). Every state has an environmental regulation that is at least as stringent as this formaldehyde standard. State regulations also may be more stringent than this standard.
Additionally, facilities that discharge waste water to Publicly Owned Treatment Works (“POTW”) or directly into navigable waters may be required to meet standards that are established by a government agency. The standard may vary for each facility depending upon the quality of the receiving water and the concentration of aldehyde found in the waste water that is discharged into the environment by industry in that area.
Waste containing aldehyde may be generated by a variety of processes. For example, aldehydes such as gluteraldehyde and ortho-phthalaldehyde (“OPA”) are used in disinfecting medical devices or instruments. Waste containing aldehydes also may be generated by painting operations, stripping operations related to floors, or other manufacturing operations.
Typically, ammonia and sodium bisulfite (“SBS”) are used to treat many aldehydes. These compounds, however, have not proven to be effective at neutralizing OPA in accordance with environmental regulations.
A waste is classified as a hazardous waste in California if the waste being examined “has an acute aquatic 96-hour LC
50
less than 500 milligrams per liter (mg/L) when measured in soft water (total hardness 40 to 48 milligrams per liter of calcium carbonate) with fathead minnows . . . ” 22 C
AL.
C
ODE
R
EGS., TIT.
22, §66696. LC
50
represents the concentration of a waste that is necessary to kill 50% of a particular animal exposed to a waste.
Note that a nonhazardous waste is generally considered by federal and state environmental agencies as a waste that does not satisfy the criteria set forth in defining a hazardous waste. Therefore, wastes generated in California that have a LC
50
>500 mg/L are nonhazardous wastes and wastes having LC
50
<500 mg/L are classified as hazardous. SBS, for example, in combination with OPA, produces a product that is generally considered hazardous under California environmental law as shown in Table 1 by LC
50
being consistently below 500 mg/L. For this study, CIDEX® OPA (commercially available from Advanced Sterilization Products®, a Johnson & Johnson Company of Irvine, Calif.) was used to supply the OPA.
TABLE 1
Neutralization Of OPA using SBS
Sample Type
OPA Content %
LC
50
(mg/l)
Comments
Fresh CIDEX ® OPA
0.301%
31.1 mg/l
1
at 0.3% OPA
Fresh CIDEX ® OPA
0.158%
50.4 mg/l
2
at 0.15% OPA
Reuse CIDEX ® OPA
0.295%
31.1 mg/l
3
at 0.3% OPA
SBS/OPA = 4:1
N/A
68.3 mg/l
4
SBS/OPA = 2:1
N/A
46.3 mg/l
5
1. Fresh CIDEX ® OPA at 0.3% OPA was prepared by diluting the fresh Cidex OPA solution with deionized water.
2. Fresh CIDEX ® OPA at 0.15% OPA was prepared by diluting the fresh Cidex OPA solution with deionized water to the level of 0.15% of OPA.
3. Reuse of CIDEX ® OPA at 0.3% OPA was prepared by diluting the simulated reuse CIDEX ® OPA (14 days) with deionized water.
4. SBS/OPA = 4:1, 10% SBS (10 ml) was combined with 100 ml of the fresh CIDEX ® OPA solution at 0.3% OPA (sample 1 above) at the SBS/OPA molar ratio of 4 to 1 for 30 minutes, and then the combined solution was used in the 22 CAL. CODE REGS., TIT. 22, § 66696 test for California.
5. SBS/OPA = 2:1, 10% SBS (5 ml) was combined with or 100 ml of the fresh CIDEX ® OPA solution at 0.3% OPA (sample 1 above)at the SBS/OPA molar ratio of 2 to 1 for 30 minutes, and then the combined solution was used for the fish test in the 22 CAL. CODE REGS., TIT. 22, § 66696 test for California.
In addition to lacking the ability to effectively neutralize OPA, ammonia and SBS are problematic since they may be harmful to the environment.
FIG. 1
shows that when OPA is combined with SBS at the molar ratio of SBS/OPA=4:0 for 30 minutes, OPA has been neutralized since the OPA concentration is nondetectable in a high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis method, which has detection limit for OPA at 10 ppm. However, the end-product is still classified as a hazardous waste as shown in Table 1. Therefore, even though the aldehyde is neutralized completely by a neutralizer, the end-product may still be a hazardous waste.
Although glycine has been shown to neutralize gluteraldehyde (see H. Y. Cheung & M. R. W. Brown, Evaluation of Glycine As An Inactivator of Gluteraldehyde, 34 J. P
HARM.
211 (1982)), the toxicity of reaction products of glycine has not been studied. Therefore, it is not known from this article whether the reaction product is nonhazardous. Accordingly, it is desirable to have a neutralizer that effectively neutralizes aldehydes in compliance with environmental standards and is less toxic to the environment.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
A method and system for neutralizing aldehydes to form a nonhazardous product is disclosed. In one aspect, the invention provides a generally nonhazardous means for neutralizing aldehydes in accordance with applicable environmental regulations prior to disposal. Additionally, the neutralization is more effective and cost efficient than traditional chemical treatment methods of aldehydes.
In one embodiment, the neutralization method comprises combining an amino acid in solution or in solid form to a contained solution (or solid form) comprising an aldehyde to form an addition product and then combining the addition product for a predetermined time to yield a nonhazardous product. A system for neutralizing an aldehyde is also disclosed.
Additional features, embodiments, and benefits will be evident in view of the figures and detailed description presented below.
REFERENCES:
patent: 7-204661 (1995-08-01), None
Seyhan Ege, Organic Chemistry, 1994, p. 534-535.*
H. Y. Cheung, M. R. W. Brown, “Evaluation of glycine as an inactivator of glutaraldehyde,” 34 J. Pharm. 211 (1982).
Chen Xiaolan
Roberts Charles G.
Blakely & Sokoloff, Taylor & Zafman
Ethicon Inc.
Griffin Steven P.
Nave Eileen E.
LandOfFree
Aldehyde neutralizer does not yet have a rating. At this time, there are no reviews or comments for this patent.
If you have personal experience with Aldehyde neutralizer, we encourage you to share that experience with our LandOfFree.com community. Your opinion is very important and Aldehyde neutralizer will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Profile ID: LFUS-PAI-O-2924546